Back to Blog
Strategy5 min read

Reddit's Playlist Promotion Fight Has Exactly One Real Dividing Line

Reddit's Playlist Promotion Fight Has Exactly One Real Dividing Line

The short answer

Reddit's full agreement stops at bot-stream services: guaranteed placement for a flat fee is a scam that can get your song delisted, no argument there. The real disagreement is whether paying a legitimate curator-pitching service for a shot at real human playlists counts as normal marketing or as selling out, and that split runs through nearly every thread on the topic. The line that actually matters is whether a service controls bots or just has relationships with curators who can still say no.

Search "spotify playlist promotion reddit" and you'll land in the middle of an argument that's been running for years without resolving, mostly because both sides are right about different things. One camp says paying anyone for playlist placement is a scam, full stop. The other says paid pitching to real, human curators is just marketing spend, same as a Spotify ad. Neither camp is actually wrong. They're describing two different services and calling them by the same name.

We've already gone deep on the bot-farm half of this argument, the mechanics of the scam, the specific companies named in Spotify's own community forums, how the stream-spike con actually works, in Reddit Nailed the Playlist Bot Scam. It's Still Arguing About the Rest. I won't rehash all of it here. But the short version matters for what follows: if a service guarantees placement for a flat fee, it isn't curating anything. It's running a bot operation wearing curation's clothes, and Spotify's artificial streaming detection eventually finds it.

The scam part isn't actually the argument anymore

Go far enough into any of these threads, on r/WeAreTheMusicMakers, on r/musicmarketing, or in Spotify's long-running Stop Playlist Scams megathread, and you'll notice the scam consensus barely gets argued anymore. Everyone agrees on the pattern: a company adds your song to a playlist you never submitted to, pumps bot streams into it, you get excited about the spike, and weeks later Spotify flags the track for artificial streaming. One poster in that megathread named the specific operators artists kept running into, including WAV.AI and a pair called WAVR.AI and ARTISTER. Trustpilot's page for a similarly pitched service, Soursz, reads like a slow-motion version of the same complaint, with one reviewer saying they were handed a fake playlist list and had their song pulled because of it.

That's not a live debate. That's a settled fact everyone's still relearning the hard way.

The real fight: pay no one, or pay the right someone

The actual disagreement starts once you take bots off the table. Some artists have concluded the whole category of paid promotion is poisoned by association, and they won't touch any of it. You see this stated almost as a vow in Spotify's community thread on paying for playlist placements: "I've never paid any promotion company for anything, and never will." Another artist, mid-dispute with their distributor over a false artificial-streaming flag, said almost the same thing, defensively this time, as proof they'd done nothing wrong: they'd never paid for promotion at all.

I get the instinct. If every bad outcome you've heard about started with a payment, "never pay" feels like the safe rule.

But the other camp has a real point too, and I think Reddit undersells it. One artist in that same discussion put the market gap plainly: there's no official Spotify promotion service, so the third-party options range from obvious scams to possibly genuine, and artists would gladly pay into an official Spotify-endorsed program if one existed. It doesn't. Spotify Ads Manager and Showcase exist, but they're audience-targeting tools, not playlist pitching. There's a real hole in the market, and "pay no one, ever" doesn't fill it, it just opts out of it. We wrote a longer breakdown of how the paid-pitching services actually differ from each other, since artists keep treating SubmitHub, Groover, and PlaylistGrow as interchangeable when they're not.

How to tell which side of the line a service is on

A few markers come up again and again in these threads, and in my experience they hold up:

  • Editorial discretion. A real curator can say no to your song. If placement is guaranteed for a fee, nothing is being curated.
  • No contact info stuffed into the playlist description. Botted playlists either have none, so you can never find a human to ask a question, or they're jammed with links funneling you toward a payment page.
  • Stream patterns that make sense. A slow build tied to actual pitching activity looks nothing like an overnight spike with no promotion behind it.
  • A curator you can vet. Follower counts, playlist history, whether they'll answer a direct question about their audience. Skipping this step is the single most common mistake artists admit to in these threads.

None of that requires trusting anyone blindly. It just requires asking the one question every scam service hates: what happens if you say no to my song?

Where we land, and why

I run curator relations for PlaylistGrow, so take this with whatever grain of salt that requires. I'd rather tell you where I actually stand than pretend to be a neutral referee on a page describing the thing I sell.

Reddit's right that the bot side of this industry is a genuine threat, not a theoretical one. We turn away far more curator relationships than we accept, for exactly the reasons described in those threads: inflated follower counts, playlists adding hundreds of tracks a day, curators who won't get on a call or answer a basic question about who's actually listening. If a service can't tell you who's on the other end of a placement, assume nobody human is.

Where I think Reddit oversimplifies is treating "paid promotion" as one category. The real split isn't paid versus free, it's bought-placement versus pitched-placement. We don't pay curators to guarantee a slot, because that's the exact practice that gets songs delisted. What we do is maintain relationships with curators running real, human-moderated playlists in specific genres, and pitch tracks into that network based on fit. Curators still say no. A lot. That's the entire point of the model.

Since 2019 we've run 2,703 campaigns for 2,418 distinct artists, resulting in 16,192 playlist placements, 6,080 of which are still active today. The genres that show up most are rap and hip-hop, Afrobeats, pop, dance and house, and R&B and soul, which tracks with where independent curator culture is strongest right now.

MetricNumber
Campaigns run to date2,703
Distinct artists served2,418
Playlist placements made16,192
Currently active placements6,080
Operating since2019 (7 years)

A placement going inactive isn't a failure, by the way. Curators refresh playlists constantly, and that's a completely different situation from a song getting pulled for fraud. If you want to see what a real campaign structure looks like before you hand money to anyone, our pricing page lays it out plainly. And if you're further back in the process, trying to get a release plan sorted before you spend on promotion of any kind, the 90-day release checklist is free and tends to head off the panic decisions that push artists toward bot services in the first place.

Reddit's suspicion of this industry isn't cynicism for its own sake. It's earned. Anyone in this business who waves it off is telling on themselves.

Common questions

Is Spotify playlist promotion legit, according to Reddit?

It's split. Artists broadly agree that services promising guaranteed placement or suspiciously fast stream spikes are scams tied to bot farms. The disagreement is over legitimate paid pitching services: some artists treat them as normal marketing spend, others refuse to pay anyone for any placement on principle.

Can paying for Spotify playlist promotion get my song removed?

Yes, if the service uses bots or click farms. Spotify's artificial streaming detection doesn't care whether you knew the plays were fake, and artists on Spotify's own community forums describe tracks getting delisted after using bot-driven playlist services.

What's the difference between a legit playlist placement and a botted one?

A legit placement comes from a real human curator who can say no to your song and whose playlist followers are actual listeners. A botted one guarantees placement for a fee and pads the results with fake streams or follower bots, which goes directly against Spotify's terms.

Is it against Spotify's rules to pay for playlist placement?

Paying someone specifically to guarantee your song gets added to a playlist violates Spotify's user guidelines. Paying a service to pitch your song to curators who keep editorial discretion over whether to add it is a different, generally accepted model.

How do artists spot fake Spotify playlist services?

Common red flags mentioned repeatedly across forums are guaranteed stream counts, contact details or payment links stuffed into playlist descriptions, and sudden unexplained stream spikes that don't match any promotion the artist actually ran.

JK
Jesse Kramer

Curator Relations at PlaylistGrow

Talks to playlist curators all day for PlaylistGrow. Knows what makes them press play, press skip, and press delete.

Get started today

Start growing your Spotify today

Join thousands of independent artists using PlaylistGrow to land real playlist placements and grow their fanbase.

See Our Plans